SUMMARY: Here’s 20 key points comms and PR needs to know about AI tools in 2025

Firstly, it is possible to be excited and worried by something all at the same time. 

The Romantic poets knew this is the sublime that things are beautiful and terrifying at the same time. William Wordsworth in ‘The Prelude’ captures these feelings from an early memory stealing a boat, rowing onto the lake and being aware of a towering cliff above him in the dark as he rowed.

 I struck and struck again,
And growing still in stature the grim shape
Towered up between me and the stars, and still,
For so it seemed, with purpose of its own
And measured motion like a living thing,
Strode after me. 

So, as with Romantic poetry and AI.

The Martech Map has been a consistently useful document in previous iterations. It is useful for tracing progress and trends in what they describe as marketing technology. Hence portmanteu martech. 

I thought it would be an idea to run their 2025 report through Google Notebook with the instruction to summarise it for a comms and PR audience who were not familiar with the topic.

Treat this as a starter for 10 and if you’re interested head back to look at what you’ve got.

For me, this is useful and the stand-out here is the speed of change and that people will need to get a hold of their data. The information being put into the AI tool will influence what it comes up with. 

20 Key Points About AI in Martech for PR and Comms Professionals

Here are 20 points summarising the impact of AI on marketing technology (martech). This summary prioritises clear, plain English to address the needs of PR and comms professionals with limited knowledge of the subject:

1. AI is rapidly transforming martech. The rate of change is much faster than with previous technological innovations.

2. The hype around AI, particularly Generative AI (GenAI), is real but the underlying technology is steadily advancing. As AI improves and finds new applications, its impact will continue to grow.

3. AI in martech isn’t just a single trend, but a multitude of interwoven trends at different stages of development. This complexity makes it challenging to make sweeping statements about AI’s overhype.

4. AI is creating five key segments within martech: Indie Tools, Challenger Platforms, Incumbent Platforms, Custom Apps, and Service-as-a-Software.

5. Indie Tools are small, specialised AI tools that excel in specific tasks. They offer a way to experiment with new AI capabilities quickly and inexpensively.

6. Challenger Platforms are AI-native companies aiming to disrupt existing platforms. They offer innovative approaches but face challenges in displacing established players.

7. Incumbent Platforms are dominant martech companies rapidly embedding AI into their products. They leverage their large user bases and resources to compete with startups.

8. Custom Apps, often built with no-code AI tools, are enabling businesses to create tailored solutions. This trend is expected to reshape tech stacks and potentially surpass commercial apps in quantity.

9. Service-as-a-Software is emerging where AI turns labour into software. This opens up a market potentially worth trillions of dollars.

10. A strong data strategy is essential for any successful AI strategy. Businesses need high-quality, well-governed data to fuel AI algorithms and achieve differentiation.

11. The modern data stack, with cloud data warehouses at its core, enables a universal data layer for martech. This provides marketers with richer customer insights by accessing data across departments.

12. A universal content layer is emerging to complement the data layer. GenAI can leverage diverse content sources to enable hyper-personalised customer engagement.

13. APIs are becoming crucial for AI agents to interact with software and achieve their goals. Martech products with strong API capabilities will be better positioned in the AI era.

14. Marketers are primarily using GenAI for content-related tasks, such as content ideation and production. Accelerating the content development pipeline is a key driver of GenAI adoption.

15. GenAI is also being used to enhance data analysis and consumption. Features like summarization and “chat with data” are empowering marketers to leverage data more effectively.

16. Governance and ethical considerations are paramount in AI adoption. Businesses need clear policies to address concerns around data privacy, security, and responsible AI usage.

17. Marketers should focus on practical use cases and resist the temptation of “AI for AI’s sake”. AI should solve real business problems and contribute to tangible outcomes.

18. Collaboration between marketing and IT is essential for successful AI implementation. Data teams can provide valuable expertise and support to marketing teams.

19. Experimentation and continuous learning are key to navigating the evolving AI landscape. Marketers should adopt an agile mindset and be willing to adapt to new developments.

20. Businesses should prioritise ownership and control over their data. This will enable them to leverage AI effectively and adapt to changing industry dynamics.
Head to martech.com for the more detailed document.

SOCIAL TABLES: Here’s the top UK 10 social media sites in 2024

It’s a changing landscape, alright.

In the UK, social media is evolving and it pays as a communicator to be across this.

So, bravo Ofcom who have published their Online Nation data which sets out in some glorious detail the numbers.

I’ll return to this data dump in the coming weeks to upgrade training slides and I’ll try and blog a snapshot for you.

I’ve used the Ofcom data to create a visualisation of the direction of travel with UK social media.

I’ve taken the data and represented it as a percentage of the UK population rather than simply users.

You can see it here:

Honestly, datamapper is an absolutely brilliant tool.

The question behind the data was ‘what platforms have you used in the previous month?’

Here’s five points on what it all means.

YouTube is the largest and gets criminally ignored

YouTube is the largest social platform in the UK. Yet, often organisation’s YouTube channels can best be described as a rag tag after thought where video gets sent to expire. At worst, they are poorly tagged, poorly labelled historic mishmash with a handful of views.

It demands the question, how can you improve what you are doing with YouTube? There’s an entire blog post in that alone.

70 per cent use Facebook, Instagram and WhatsApp

Elsewhere in the report, is the gem that seven in ten in the UK are using the Meta triumverate of Facebook, Insta and WhatsApp.

Frustratingly, Ofcom have stopped including messenging apps in the numbers which isn’t ideal. So, WhatsApp aren’t in this top 10. Elsewhere in the report, data shows that 87 per cent of UK people use WhatsApp monthly and 64 per cent use it daily.

That makes WhatsApp the most used messenger – or social – app in the UK.

X, formerly Twitter is falling

The decline is real. Year on year Elon Musk’s platform has dropped by eight per cent. The data for this report is from May 2024 so it predates the UK and US elections. I would not be surprised if the figures heralded a larger drop next year.

The only surprise I have at this is that it hasn’t fallen further.

No Nextdoor

In previous years, I’ve seen Nextdoor in the top 10 but in 2024 that’s not the case. Nextdoor is a community-based platform that has some advantages for public sector organisations.

Not cropping up in this list would suggest the platform may be in decline.

Reddit… ruddy hell

Reddit is up by an astonishing 47 per cent on the 2024 Ofcom list. Reddit is described as a platform where users curate information by voting on it in specific communities. So, there are Reddits for a whole range of subjects. Two thirds of Reddit users are under 29 and they tend to be more tech savvy.

In the past, I’ve heard of great strides in creating ads on Reddit. I’d be interested to see how this goes for people.

TikTok is up

The rise of TikTok continues. After Reddit, it has the largest rise in Ofcom’s table of stats up 13 per cent. A third of the UK uses this vertical video platform.

The fact it is not longer the sexiest on the block in 2024 – BlueSky may have that – in a curious way makes it more of a proposition. Things often get interesting when they are boring.

Snapchat is still here

One of the biggest strategic mistakes you can make is to base your organisation’s output based on what you or the chief exec likes. It can be the block to TikTok in many places. For me, this can be folly as you skew your channels away from your audience.

I don’t use Snapchat but if I was trying to reach young people that’s a platform I’d be looking at. The numbers here remain strong for the platform used most by teenagers.

Whatabout Threads and BlueSky?

Whatabout them indeed. The cool kids are all about BlueSky but neither they or Meta’s Threads are in the top 10. Both were launched as being Twitter killers.

Buried in the Ofcom report is the insight that there are 5.3 million active Threads users in the UK in May 2024. There’s no data I’ve come across yet for BlueSky.

I hope this list helps you think of what your comms needs to look like in 2025.

Training I deliver:

ESSENTIAL COMMS SKILLS REBOOTED

ESSENTIAL MEDIA RELATIONS

ESSENTIAL VIDEO SKILLS REBOOTED

ESSENTIAL VERTICAL VIDEO FOR TIKTOK & REELS

WATCHING BRIEF: How to approach BlueSky for the public sector

I’ve been asked a few times around BlueSky and whether or not that’s the new Twitter for the public sector.

It’s a reasonable question to ask. 

But I’m going to be slightly less on the excitement gauge than others.

Firstly, the data argument. The numbers are not yet there to compare it to X, formerly Twitter. BlueSky is not in the top 10 of social accounts used by UK people.

There are thought to be 20 million BlueSky users globally and in all likelihood the UK there will be hundreds of thousands of users. The platform is dwarfed by Meta’s Threads which has 275 million monthly users in late 2024.

Secondly, there’s the subjective yardstick of the question ‘is this the new Twitter?’. Well, if it was, we wouldn’t be asking ourselves that question.

In the 1990s, when cricketing all-rounder Ian Botham’s powers were on the wane a platoon of candidates were wheeled in and out as ‘the new Ian Botham’. So we had David Capel, Phil deFreitas and Derek Pringle all hyped as the next big thing only to fall below that once-in-a-generation benchmark.

It was only when we stopped looking for the new Botham that we got Andrew Flintoff. And he was his own person.

How to approach a new channel like BlueSky

I’m going to fall back on some good advice when dealing with BlueSky. I’d recommend the same to you.

It’s the same advice I used for Google Plus, Google Wave, Mastodon and other next big things. I’m going to spend some time with them under my own steam to see how they work and suggest you do too. A month minimum. Only when the smoke and mirrors clears I’d think about using it in earnest as a corporate account.

While you spend time off your own bat with BlueSky you can start to see if there’s value for you. If there is, fantastic. You may connect with some really interesting people and you’ll tap into good knowledge. This may be as far as it goes.

The watching brief approach also gives you the chance to be on the front foot with the organisation. You will get the chief executive or some senior person asking about what you’re doing with BlueSky. They’ll have read something, you see, 

So, get ahead of that, be proactive, do the research and tell them you’re doing the research. You don’t want to be put on the spot. You absolutely don’t want to be ordered to do something you don’t think has value.

Understanding BlueSky

Alan Morrison on LinkedIn has written a useful opener to understand BlueSky. Rob Preston has also blogged on BlueSky from a charities perspective. I also enjoyed Madeleine Sugden’s post on BlueSky tips

If you’re used to old Twitter you’ll find some features are familiar. 

By all means reserve a corporate BlueSky account in the meantime but I wouldn’t be investing serious time into it just yet. If you do, do so as a trial. 

In the public sector, there is still value in X/Twitter as a platform to reach journalisms and MPs.So, for me right now the filter for your corporate Twitter should be content you want to pitch to journos and politicians. 

I keep saying this, but there’s been more change in the past 12 to 18 months with the media landscape than there has in the past 12 years. 

That’s not going to change.

Understanding this is how we’ll earn our money.

NEWS STAND: Some thoughts on avoiding the news

I go through phases with my news consumption, do you?

Some weeks I’ll consume everything. All the news all the commentary and all the opinion on the commentary. A whirling gyre of thoughts and impressions that never fully resolves itself. It just gets taken over by the next one.

Other times, I hang back. Part of lockdown was like that. I’d maybe check the BBC headlines once a day and then leave it at that.

Right now, I’m largely switched off from news. Gaza, Israel, Ukraine. It’s all bad. The news that America has voted for, lets face it, fascism, is just enough. It feels as though I need to save my resilience.

Four in ten in the UK avoid the news, research has shown.

Of course, as a former reporter I feel a moral obligation to consume news and as a voter I need to know what’s going on, right?

This passage in an email I’m subscribed to is from ‘Please Scream Inside Your Heart: Breaking News From the Year That Wouldn’t End‘ by Dave Pell chimes with me.

“The notion that you need to know about world events right when they happen is a marketing creation of media brands. And yet, those news stories mingle in the same lock screen with the personal reminders and calls from your mom. The stuff that has something to do with you is now almost impossible to distinguish from the stuff that doesn’t. Trust me, that news alert can wait until later. Like most things on the internet, it can wait until never. You’re not Batman. You’re not going to do anything about the news alerts, so they can wait. As a general rule, you don’t need to be immediately notified of any breaking news that’s happening more than about eighteen feet from where you are right now. At most, your alerts should only cover your locality. Even Bruce Wayne only covers Gotham.”

REVEALED: The drift away from corporate X/Twitter in numbers

There’s been a lot of debate about how organisations use X/Twitter in recent months but what are the numbers?

Now, any data around any social media platform are notoriously opaque and in the coming months Ofcom will no doubt publish annual UK data.

Ahead of all that, I ran a survey to see where people are in the public sector and third sector with their corporate accounts.

The numbers while unscientific are fascinating.

In the public sector, a quarter are heading for the exit

It’s clear that there is a lot of reflection going on with the public sector corporate account.

For the public sector, a quarter are going or have gone. That’s a similar number for those who are staying put.

Those who have departed are three times as likely to do so on the quiet by simply stopping using it rather than making a grand public announcement.

For me, that’s a canny bit of judgement given the wall of abuse some organisations have been met with when they’ve publicly quit.

But just over half of organisations have yet to make their minds up.

In the third sector, two thirds are evaluating

There’s even more head scratching going on in the charity sector with X, formerly Twitter.

More than 60 per cent are evaluating their corporate presence. On top of that, one in 10 have decided to stay with almost a quarter going or gone.

Is this the right decision?

Of course, there is no universal correct decision for a corporate account. There is a trend to head to the exits for UK public sector and third sector but this was never going to be an overnight event. Platforms don’t work like that. They tend to grow slowly and then fade away.

There are several factors to take account of. Firstly, I’ve blogged that journalists and MPs are performing strongly on the platform. The same analysis showed that routine public sector content was failing to cut through.

So, would these numbers suggest there’s still a role for connecting with journalists and MPs? Absolutely. There’s been some talk about journos moving to Bluesky. It’ll be interesting to see how this pans out.

In any event, I’d be highly surprised if prominent MPs or Government departments left X/Twitter. This would leave the field clear for their political opponents.

What the data absolutely shows is that the tectonic plates of the internet are on the move.

RESEARCH: What percentage of X followers now see content?

A few months back, I blogged about the conversations now taking place in comms team about leaving X, formerly Twitter.

As with anything with social media there were some strong opinions so I tried to keep it as dispassionate as possible. You can read the post here.

The Guardian has now re-fired the debate with their news they were stopping using the platform and in turn that has led to people to take a fresh look at how their organisation uses the platform.

So, I thought I’d take a look at an additional question. How many are actually SEEING what’s being posted onto X, formerly Twitter?

Using publicly available data I pulled together this list.

I worked out the total number of people who had seen the last 20 tweets the account had posted, worked out an average and then measured that as a percentage of their follower numbers.

Here’s a datamapper visualisation…

What’s clear is that journalists and politicians are still getting their content seen.

After all, social media loves the new, loves opinions and loves outrage. So, journos and political leaders perform well.

But what about the public sector? Well, that’s a different case.

I’ve tried to reflect at random elements of local government, fire & rescue, police and NHS. How do they perform? Not so great.

One council has 0.1 percent of their follower numbers seeing their tweets.

There’s no implied criticism of any of those account admins. Who knows, if there’s a busy week those figures may rise. During the awful murders in Southport and the following riots across towns in England its possible that those tweets travelled far further. Should X, formerly Twitter be reserved for just emergencies?

What’s clear, is that the audience for many accounts has moved on.

I carry out social media reviews for bright people looking to make sense of a changing landscape.

ROBOT NEWS: What AI holds for newsrooms… and media relations

Because the pace of change is increasing and because I’ve been playing with Google Notebook I thought I’d ask the tool to summarise the new Reuters whitepaper.

This document Powering Trust News With AI: Navigating the Present and Trusting the Future looks at how artificial intelligence with affect news rooms, or rather, what’s left of them.

This came via UK Press Gazette. I’ve looked, can’t find the link I’ve added a wetransfer link to the Reuters report here.

So, in the spirit of AI, here is a summary of how AI can be used in news and communications, in 10 bullet points, for an audience of communications and public relations people:

AI presents both opportunities and risks for the news and media industry. While it can enhance news reporting and delivery, there are concerns about misinformation, the rapid pace of AI development, and potential threats to intellectual property.

AI can revolutionise newsrooms by improving workflow efficiencies. One example is Avista, an AI-powered tool developed by Reuters that helps clients quickly find specific video segments.

Maintaining trust and journalistic integrity in the age of AI is crucial. At Reuters, AI tools are evaluated based on their ability to support the company’s mission of delivering unbiased and important news stories.

Human oversight remains essential. Editors and journalists should retain control and carefully review AI-generated content to ensure accuracy and ethical standards.

There are three key ways AI can be integrated into workflows: replacing tasks humans don’t need to do, augmenting existing work, and facilitating innovative experiments.

Combating misinformation is a top priority. AI algorithms can help detect fake news, images, and videos.

AI literacy is essential for navigating the evolving media landscape. News organisations and consumers need to be aware of the capabilities and limitations of AI.

Generative AI tools like ChatGPT are changing audience expectations. The media industry must adapt to meet the demand for faster and more personalised content delivery.

AI can help news organisations stay relevant in a changing media landscape. This includes using AI to optimise content discoverability and deliver information efficiently while maintaining safeguards.

The future of AI in media will likely involve increased automation to handle tasks such as translation and transcription. This will free up journalists to focus on in-depth, unbiased reporting from trusted sources.

Firstly, a useful summary using Google Notebook which I increasingly love. Its benefit is that it works with what you give it rather than pulling things from across the internet like ChatGPT.

What this means for comms and PR

Firstly, it’s clear that thev relationship between reporters and media relations is evolving. Some things still stay the same. For me, the definition of news remains information that somebody somewhere doesn’t want you to know.

But beyond that definition, the landscape is changing. With misinformation, we can rightly be focused on what bad actors may try and do with content. We are looking to respected news titles to be a major bullwark against misinformation. It’s try they are a bullwark. But I don’t think communications needs to sit back and relax.

So, if news titles, and sorry I’m calling them that rather than news brands, are looking to invest in tools to weed out misinformation and disinformation then that’s something public sector comms needs to look at.

What’s also really interesting is the line that AI tools are changing audience expectation. If they think news titles should be getting better at delivering targeted information that’s something the institutions of state need to look at. That includes the NHS, councils, fire and police, too.

CREATIVE INSPIRATION: 44 present ideas for comms and PR

While it is down to Noddy Holder to decide whether or not it’s Christmas you can never be too early in getting ready for present ideas.

Here are 44 ideas that I’ve bookmarked over the past few months.

Dig in.

A Bag of F***s to Give

Here’s one when you are at your wits end.

Wilddrootss£13.03

Public Relations specialist mug

Good coffee is essential to the creative process and this one is a reminder of your skills.

Zazzle £18.20

‘The Coming Wave: AI, Power and Our Future’ by Mustafa Suleyman

‘I’ve lost count of the number of people I’ve recommended this to. Useful as a start for AI.’

Amazon £8.99

A Here We F***ing Go Again 2025 Calendar

Because sometimes you need to roll your eyes and count to 10 in calendar form.

Eshoppe

Five star colleague badge

A pocket-money priced reminder for each of your colleagues.

Etsy £1.25

WTF needlepoint pillow

This dropped into my timeline on Facebook and I loved the mix of craft, needlework and WTF.

Maison Flaneur £60

Smartphone projector

Because that film you made deserves a cinematic showing.

Flying Tiger £15

1980s postal labels

I love this sort of thing.

Present and Correct £4

‘Make it Now Make it New’ notebook

Fred Aldous is a stationary shop I love in the Northern Quarter of Manchester. I love the optimism in this cover.

Fred Aldous £19.20

You can’t do epic sh*t with basic people keyring

A reminder of the basics.

Flamingo Candles £3.95

Travel electric lunchbox

I’ve got one of these. It’s really handy if you are on the road or in the office to warm up last night’s leftovers. Big recommend.

Amazon£24.99

1950s metal desk in-tray

There is something wonderfully analogue about things from Sukie. Who wouldn’t want a metal in-tray?

Sukie £35

Personalised birthday hat bunting

Because there may be people you know and love who deserve this.

Printed Little Things £14.99

‘I Don’t Know What I’m Doing’ poster

And that’s fine. You think I’ve got a plan?

Drool £35

Story board sticky notes

I love the quirkiness of these.

Etsy £19.41

‘Relax and Ignore’ poster

Sound advice at times for your WFH office space.

PSTR Studio £45

‘Arrows of Desire’ by Nick Job

This is an intriguing read on how the British Rail logo was developed and how it works.

The Modernist £24

‘Everything Will Kill You So Choose Somethiung Fun’ poster

Useful reminder.

Printervall £6.99

‘Scrolling less creating more’ poster

Innit, though.

The Smallprint Co £40

Wildfire Mayhem emergency planning board game

This is based on man actual event made by a fire and rescue expert who works on big fires like this.

Emergency Operations Center Board Game Kickstarter

This is Marketing by Seth Godin

A useful way to look at marketing.

Amazon 11.69

Turns Out These Are My Monkeys And This Is My Circus’ picture

A handy reminder of the important stuff.

Chic Prints £11.99

‘The Art of Explanation’ by Ros Atkins

Ros Atkins is the BBC reporter who makes those excellent well researched explainer videos you’ve seen. There are some good pointers here.

Amazon £8.89

Reusable coffee cup

Because a re-usable coffee cup you can take with you is a positive thing and you can help Shelter the homeless charity.

Shelter £4.99

Double walled cafetiere

I’ve found that metal cafeteries work better for me than glass ones. I’ve broken loads of those.

Habitat 24.50

Felt potted plants for your desktop

Your workspace needs to have some splash of greenery to make it more human. You won’t have to remember to water them, either.

Baltic Shop £8.95

As per my last email coaster

Passive aggressive means of keeping your table free of coffee spills.

Etsy £4.99

We’ll fix it on post mug

For the film maker in your life.

Red Bubble £11.69

‘Buzzing Communities’ by Richard Millington

This is an excellent book that I go back to time and time over. It’ll help you understand why engaging people online is worth it.

Amazon £15

Dramatic Exit print

I love this. You know the online dramatic exit? Now you can do it real life.

Lune Club £9.99

Dot, dot, dot sticky notes

Good stationary.

Etsy £7.76

Personalised wine prescription label

Funny. But be careful. Wine is not your friend in the morning.

Etsy £2.99

Java blend 3 out of 5 strength for cafeteria

I’ve bought this from this shop before and it’s full value.

Algerian Cogffee Stores £5.20 plus postage

‘Do / Story’ by Bobette Buster

I’ve recommended this to many people. It’s a good read with solid gold advice.

Amazon £8.95

Uniball pen pack

Without good pens I can’t do good work.

Amazon £13.80

Ordnance Survey app

People talk about the importance of fresh air and exercise and then often don’t follow it up. The OS app was my discovery in lockdown when we couldn’t travel far.

OS from £6.99

Blank planning graph print block

I’ve spent a small fortune on daily printed planning sheets. This is a bit more home made.

Etsy £10.98

Ink block

For the printer’s block.

Amazon £7.99

Indestructible’ by Molly McPherson

A really, really good book for dealing with a media crisis.

Amazon £14.50

Brownies

I’ve sent many boxes of these through the post.

Gower Cottage Brownies £19.99

‘Mentally, I’m Malcolm Tucker’ sticker

You get the sticker rather than the drinks bottle with this but it’s a timely reminder to be more the Thick Of It character.

Red Bubble £1.51

Tripod for mobile phone

Handy as you can wrap this around things when you are out shooting.

Amazon £16.99

Cadbury’s Dairy Milk

A 21-bar pack. There’s no messing around here. A perfect way to motivate the team.

Amazon £29.92

Old bingo cards

I love the typography of this.

Present & Correct £2

US ELECT: 15 things communicators can learn from the Trump v Harris 2024 campaign

If its true that elections are petri dishes for communications ideas then the 2024 US Presidential Election is the biggest laboratory of them all.

If its also true that the polls on November 5 will be decided by a few thousand voters in seven swing states then the work around the edges may well decide who runs the free world.

Now, this post is not an exhaustive analysis of both campaigns but more a distanced look at what headline strategies from Harris and Trump can teach us.

Analysts in the days before polling day say that Trump is all about firing up his base by making them angry while Harris is going after undecided voters.

“It’s all pieces of a very complex puzzle,” Harris senior campaign adviser David Plouffe told AP. “This would all be a simpler exercise if you can focus just on one voter cohort. You can’t. And you got to make sure you know you’re doing well enough with all of them so that when you put all that together it adds up to 50 per cent.”

This may seem extreme to a UK audience. Actually, this is just a 10-storey technicolour version of the UK landscape. We don’t consume the media in the same way. A 16-year-old glued to a mobile phone takes on information in a different way to a 66-year-old BBC News watcher.

But what about the comms in the Trump v Harris fight?

It’s not all about the corporate account

If it came down to a straight head to head battle of social media account followers then Donald Trump would be going straight back to The White House. He outguns Kamala Harris massively. It’s a 13 to 1 win on follower count across social media channels. It’s not even close.

His Twitter account’s 95.4 million followers is the jewel in his crown but he also is outfollowing his opponent over on TikTok, Facebook and Instagram, too

That Harris is still even in the race is because they have tapped into other accounts and networks. For example, Taylor Swift’s endorsement to her 283 million Instagram followers or her 32 million supporters on TikTok.

It’s about going to where the eyeballs are in mainstream media

Kamala Harris on Saturday Night Live, for example. That’s not changed. Kids, Google ‘Bill Clinton + sax.’

It’s about the supporter Facebook groups

Both Harris and Trump have their own supporter Facebook groups toi reinforce the message. For example, the Democratic Voices for Harris / Walz 2024 has 44,000 members while Trump Train MAGA fan club has 52,000. Both have some pretty extreme content.

It’s about the bait and switch supporter Facebook groups

Intriguing, there’s evidence of Facebook groups being set-up posing as pro-Harris but then feed followers attack content.

It’s about supporters posting in Facebook groups

A strategy that Labour and the Conservatives in the UK have developed.

It’s about the memes

Just as in the UK General Election, images with text rule. They capture a moment and can be forwarded within seconds to supporters’ networks. For each micro-campaign moment there are memes with many originating from the centre. This leads to…

It’s about speeding up the approvals process

In 2016, Hilary Clinton’s team took up to 12 staffers and 10 drafts to write a tweet. In 2024, Kamala Harris’ team of five for TikTok can go from idea to execution to approval within half an hour. That’s a deliberate strategy and can put them ahead of the curve.

It’s about using people who know the platform

Harris has a team of five on TikTok who know the platform backwards, know what works and know what will fly. They are given the keys, minimal sign-off and get on with it. The lime green colours and Arial typeface inspired by Charlie XCX came from this. So did the range of content.

It’s about bespoke content for the platform

It works on TikTok? Great. Let it work there. It won’t work on X, formerly Twitter. So don’t try.

It’s about using translations on niche platforms

Harris has also used Spanish language content to target the Latino electorate with content on WhatsApp because it is a key channel. It is not about the one piece of content to rule them all approach. It is about splintered and bespoke.

It’s about stunts v campaigning

Trump’s campaign, analysts have detected, has been about stunts to skew the debate rather than detailed policy discussion. For example, the stunt of Trump working in McDonalds for the day dominated the content for days overshadowing Harris. But the Trump rally which saw a speaker abuse Peurto Ricans was a stunt in reverse. It backfired leading to community leaders distancing themselves from Trump.

It’s about AI misinformation

Responsible reporting on the election records alarming stories of Twitter users paid to spread fake content, Iranian and Russian influence, fake audio of Joe Biden and fake images. With a few days to go there has not been a single defining piece of fake content. But maybe that’s the danger. There are not enough eyeballs to monitor everything posted. Or maybe Time magazine is right in calling the risk of AI something of a fake alarm.

It’s the language of the fan account

The language of the corporate account reflects the platform not the politician on Kamala Harris’ account. Commentator Rachel Karten likens this to a fan account. “It’s not like it’s coming from a campaign,” she writes. “It’s like: We talk like you. Even the caption is like: ‘You have to watch this.’”

It’s ANGER-tainment

One particularly prescient piece of commentary was that it’s a mistake to compare Harris and Trump as two politicians. They are not. One is a politician while the other, Donald Trump, is a consummate exponent of angertainment. This is the blended mix of anger and entertainment that Trump has been brilliant at. His content is about getting a REACTION rather than a reasoned response. So, in that context it makes sense that he talks about pointing guns pointing at Liz Cheney’s face. While Harris is telling people how terrible Trump is she’s not talking about her own message.

It’s not just about polling day

I’m writing this before election day. Last time there was an election in the US there was an insurrection because someone couldn’t accept the fact they lost. I don’t think that the story of the election ends when the results are announced.

Reporters are talking about the Democrats having a strong ground operation with people knocking on doors and turning the vote out. Republicans have instead invested in lawyers to challenge the vote.

That’s not something I hope the UK takes on board.

PRESS POST: Where indie news is in 2024 and why you should be bothered

One of the best meetings I ever had in my time in local government was post-2011 riots with police and bloggers.

There we were at Wolverhampton police station, two police Superintendents, four bloggers and me from Walsall Council.

It wasn’t, as the saying goes, an interview without coffee but more a constructive chat.

While riots had gripped other parts of the country, our part of the West Midlands had avoided the worst of it. In part, this was because the Superintendents had used Twitter to shoot down rumours in real time as they emerged. 

The bloggers would spot the rumour and one of the officers would shoot them down.

It was a remarkably effective tactic and it became the cornerstone for how we tackled emergency planning. 

If you think that’s common sense, you’ll have to remember that the Metropolitan Police were actively discussing how to make a kill switch to turn the internet off at a time of crisis. No, really. They were.

As the meeting ended and we filed out, it only then occurred to me that the local regional paper wasn’t there. Why? Because they didn’t use social media and preferred if people waited until the next day to find what had been going on. No, really, they did.

Why journalism is important

In really simple terms, a source of information makes people more informed so they are more likely to vote. There is more faith in the process if they can see it being held to account. 

Without this oil, the democratic process and community cohesion, that ability to get along suffers.

Yes, public sector comms people will often swear about a particular reporter or publication but on balance they are a necessary part of society. 

The promise of local bloggers 

Around 2009, former civil servant Will Perrin launched the Talk About Local project to promote and explore the idea that a new generation of journalism would emerge. Concerned citizens armed with laptops would start new local news sites.

The movement was helped by thenlocal government minister Eric Pickles who insisted that bloggers – or anyone – could tweet or livestream from public meetings.

In the West Midlands, some good sites emerged such as, WV11 in Wolverhampton, A Little Bit of Stone and Lichfield Live in Staffordshire and the unrelated Telford Live in Shropshire emerged. There were some good debates about how much press officers should support those blogs. I was very much in the ‘treat them like journalists’ camp. 

Some of those sites fell away or morphed into Facebook groups. Brownhills Bob’s Facebook group has a staggering 56,000 members. But that early promise of a revolution in the sector never really took hold. It’s hard holding down a job in the day then holding your council to account at night.

So, where is alternative news today?

Two things I want to flag up with you.

Alternative news is a £24.6m economy

Firstly, the Public Interest News Foundation. This is a UK-Government funded project to map alternative news providers. I was surprised to read that there are the best part of 400 websites and radio stations across the UK that cover news in one form or another.

Their 2024 report is a useful read as it sets out the impact of these sites. There are around 350,000 unique users per site which makes them potentially influential. Many are affiliated with regulators such as Ofcom or Ipsos which gives additional confidence to their standards.

In some parts of the UK, where there are news deserts, coverage of news by an independent provider is all there is. 

Their map of indie news sites is worth a look if you’re wondering if there’s one in your area.

Email first providers 

Aside from that,, a new generation of news providers has emerged that follow an email-first strategy. Mill Media secured funding to launch publications in Manchester, Sheffield, Birmingham and Liverpool with sites in Glasgow and London to follow.

Refreshingly, these publications are not powered by clicks but subscribers. So, three or four stories a day are published to subscribers. Those who have opted into the paid model get more content. They are a deeper dive. 

The Manchester Mill site tells the story: “The idea was very simple: would people start valuing and paying for local news again if it was done in a completely different way? More in-depth; more nuanced; with stories that were more enjoyable to read and weren’t covered in horrible advertising.”

I’ve been meaning to research what these look like for some time but haven’t had the time to go through the numbers. 

So, what?

Of course, the acid test for public sector comms is so what? Independent media isn’t poised to replace traditional media. There won’t be say, Blog Preston sellers in the streets although many providers have experimented with print. The money isn’t there in the sector squeezed by Google and Facebook but this can be an extra voice in the community.

Yes, they could carry your campaign message but they may well want to ask you questions. Like the reporter v press officer relationship this can ebb and flow.

This is how its supposed to be.